ElgarBlog

By Andrea Parziale

Two people suffer comparable injuries and bring comparable claims. Both are entitled, in principle, to full compensation for their pain, suffering and loss of amenity. Yet they may walk away with markedly different sums, for reasons that have little to do with what they have lost: which adjudicator hears the case, which jurisdiction is competent, when the claim is filed, how the evidence is presented. This is what has long been called the ‘damages lottery’. Beyond complicating settlements and inflating costs, it strains the most basic expectation we have of law: that like cases be decided alike.

The root of the difficulty is incommensurability. Hospital bills and lost wages have market prices; pain has none. The principle of full compensation tells us that non-economic losses must be compensated, but it supplies neither a metric nor a method for doing so. In response, a growing number of European legal systems have turned to guidelines and tables. The lottery, however, has not disappeared.

Breaking the Damages Lottery asks why. The prevailing explanation, developed largely in behavioural law and economics, points to the decision-maker’s mind: anchoring, framing, and susceptibility to legally irrelevant cues. Yet the lottery is also a problem of institutional architecture. Adjudicators applying the same table can reach materially different awards because the table itself leaves key steps of quantification undetermined. Cognitive biases operate within a space shaped by guideline design.

The book first maps the guidelines and tables used across fourteen EU Member States, proposing a functional typology that looks beyond the familiar binary of binding and advisory instruments to ask what relationship each one establishes between conventional instruction and adjudicative discretion. It then examines five systems in depth (Belgium, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands and Sweden), drawing on a systematic case-law review, interviews with adjudicators and multi-stakeholder focus groups conducted within my Marie Skłodowska-Curie project, FullCompensation. Across very different legal traditions, the evidence points to recurring structural weaknesses: guidelines that leave unclear how baseline values should be set, that lack firm rules for concurrent injuries, and that permit personalisation without saying which factors justify departing from the baseline, or by how much.

This diagnosis grounds the book’s normative argument. Because non-economic losses are incommensurable, the choice between discretion and standardisation ultimately reduces to one between individual and collective arbitrariness. I argue, somewhat counterintuitively, that strong standardisation, under specific conditions, can promote not only equal treatment but also genuine personalisation: uniform baseline values must be accompanied by sufficiently numerous, specific, objective and easily ascertainable personalising factors, each with a stated monetary weight. The book takes seriously the objections this invites, from human dignity and judicial independence to the risk of capture by insurers and other powerful interests.

Breaking the Damages Lottery is written for scholars of comparative tort law and judicial decision-making, and for policymakers considering how to reform their own compensation systems in light of experience elsewhere. Its underlying question, however, concerns anyone interested in how law responds to harm: how can a legal order take individual suffering seriously while still treating like cases alike? The book offers a diagnosis and a principled answer. I invite readers to test both against the full argument.


Andrea Parziale is an Assistant Professor of Comparative Private Law at the Institute of Law, Politics and Development, Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies, Pisa, Italy

Breaking the Damages Lottery is published by Edward Elgar Publishing.

Purchase a hard copy

Purchase the eBook

Leave a Reply